Go Back   Mom Talk > Public > Children > Babies and Toddlers

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 12-09-2007, 04:16 PM   #1
Garrulous Empress Talkaloticus
 
BigNutbrownHare's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 7,076
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
Default Why no milk before 1yo?

Someone remind me again why the general rule of thumb is no cow's milk before 1yo. Allergies? Stomach sensitivities to the complex proteins? Hormones in milk? My mom's new idea for getting Anna to eat is to "just give her cow's milk already" and before I even start that fight I want to be prepared. I tried googling it and all I came up with is a bunch of blogs about moms who can't drink milk while nursing, or diets for lactose intolerant kids.
BigNutbrownHare is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:16 PM   #2
Champion of Chat
 
ThatSuzyGirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Pemberley
Posts: 3,932
ThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond repute
ThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond reputeThatSuzyGirl has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

I think it is part allergies and part a reaction to our parents generation who were advised to put us on cows milk as soon as they could. The proteins aren't good enough for a developing brain. Cows grow great muscles and bones but cow brains aren't so smart...

Suzy
ThatSuzyGirl is offline  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:24 PM   #3
Resident Food Nazi
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: dreaming of the beach.....
Posts: 3,632
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

Dr. Jim (Sears) gives a solid answer that should quiet your MIL! Good luck!

AskDrSears.com - FAQ "MILK VS. YOGURT FOR BABIES"
bugginsmom is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:34 PM   #4
Stuck in the 90s
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Out
Posts: 5,124
sarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond repute
sarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

I haven't looked at Erika's link (which I'm sure has it all...I love Dr. Sears' website!), but one reason our ped gave us was that cow's milk doesn't have the same amount of iron and other good stuff that breast milk and formula have. HOWEVER, he also said that past about 10 months or so, it is fine to give it too them in small quantities to work up to giving them just milk when they are 1 year. As long as their tummies can handle it, it won't hurt them as they are nearing 1 year.
sarasuzy is offline  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:38 PM   #5
Garrulous Empress Talkaloticus
 
BigNutbrownHare's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 7,076
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

So yogurt can only start at 9mo (based on the article Erika posted) too? That is going to be her next question.
BigNutbrownHare is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:40 PM   #6
Resident Food Nazi
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: dreaming of the beach.....
Posts: 3,632
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

Yes, we did start yogurt at 9 months. We used whole milk yogurt by Stoneyfield Farms. We did plain yogurt, but they do have the YoBaby yogurt in little cups with different flavors too.
bugginsmom is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:46 PM   #7
Garrulous Empress Talkaloticus
 
BigNutbrownHare's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 7,076
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
BigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond reputeBigNutbrownHare has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

Ash still eats the Stoneyfield Farms YoBaby cups!

Thanks girls - my mom is really trying to help and honestly with the drama that DD is putting me through, I would consider it if it weren't bad for her. Only two and a half months until I can try yogurt with her - maybe that will help!
BigNutbrownHare is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 05:53 PM   #8
Stuck in the 90s
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Out
Posts: 5,124
sarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond repute
sarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond reputesarasuzy has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

I think you can give yogurt earlier than 9 months...babycenter says 8 months. I feel like we tried it even earlier than that with Annie, but she didn't like it, so she didn't have much.
sarasuzy is offline  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2007, 07:46 PM   #9
wants to be FABULOUS.
 
lapoissonne's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: still trying to figure that out
Posts: 8,828
lapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond repute
lapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond reputelapoissonne has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

Quote:
Originally Posted by lovethecitylife View Post
So yogurt can only start at 9mo (based on the article Erika posted) too? That is going to be her next question.

Christine has had Yogurt for almost a month now...It regulated her digestive system and she LOVES it. I always started foods way earlier and my kids always seemed to do fine. I will probably start eggs soon since she likes to feed herself and I need some more soft foods for her to pick up. I get the Yo Baby and she eats all the flavors. Buys me time when she is too busy to nurse. She did take three ounces out of a Medela pump bottle today (first time in about FIVE MONTHS!) and I was very happy about that!
lapoissonne is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 12-10-2007, 03:45 AM   #10
Resident Food Nazi
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: dreaming of the beach.....
Posts: 3,632
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
bugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond reputebugginsmom has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Why no milk before 1yo?

Just as a reference, I checked my American Academy of Pediatrics and it states that you can start yogurt at 8 months, which is when I did, I think. I second what Sarah said about all of the great digestive bacterias the yogurt gives too!
bugginsmom is online now  
Add Post to del.icio.usFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Reply




Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

 

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
More Milk Plus BigNutbrownHare Product and Merchant Reviews 2 12-20-2007 01:40 PM
milk, milk, milk, milk, milk KBtotheBB Pregnancy 21 12-09-2007 01:12 PM
Gas/Milk Prices Vanesa Chatter 16 11-14-2007 08:28 AM
milk supply akagirl Pregnancy 6 10-20-2007 02:52 PM
Here comes the milk! lapoissonne Pregnancy 2 03-18-2007 03:49 PM


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:03 PM.